Bad Bosses Curb Young Ambition
British businesses risk losing young talent because of poor management, according to new research released by the Institute of Leadership and Management (ILM).
Nearly 400,000 UK workers aged 18-24 feel that their manager is holding them back. And British businesses are in danger of losing these future leaders, as one quarter (27 per cent) of young workers would leave their organisation if they were badly managed.
Bad bosses are putting many young workers off management altogether. Twice as many young people who have had a negative management experience don't want to become a manager in the future (28 per cent), compared with those who get on well with their superiors (14 per cent).
The lack of strong leadership in British businesses is also breeding cynicism in young people, with 25 per cent of young workers believing that they could do a better job than their current manager.
Old style, dictatorial management practices top the list of management don'ts, with 60 per cent of respondents saying that they most dislike a manager who looks for someone to blame. Managers who expect staff to do as they're told without debate, those who don't allow staff to contribute and those who are obstructive are also unpopular.
Young people want progressive management to inspire them - 86 per cent of the younger generation put approachability at the top of the list when it comes to desirable management traits, followed by letting staff 'get on with the job' (66 per cent), being team-focused (47 per cent) and consultative (47 per cent).
And they're an ambitious bunch, as 40 per cent of young workers say they would like to manage a team of their own within five years.
Despite the poor perception of today's bosses, 61 per cent of future leaders expect to learn about management directly from their own managers. This highlights the need for quality management training at all levels in order to ensure it is good practice that is being passed down throughout organisations.
Kim Parish, Chief Executive of the Institute of Leadership & Management comments:
'It's imperative that we develop our young talent because they have no qualms about moving on. Young people will leave organisations if they experience poor management and that, combined with the increasing trend for portfolio careers, means that businesses risk losing the talent they have put so much time, money and effort into recruiting and developing.
'This adds to the challenges for today's managers - not only must they deliver results, inspire customers and cut costs, but they must involve their team, even when the going gets tough. It's a tall order. Now more than ever managers need support and development; organisations investing in management qualifications and professional development for their staff will be the winners.'
Methodology
The research was undertaken by YouGov between 18 and 25 July 2006 and surveyed 496 18-24 year olds in full-time employment, across a range of UK regions and industry sectors. Out of 496 respondents, a sample of 487 had a line manager.
Key statistics
- One in ten (11 per cent) feel that their manager is holding them back
- One quarter (27 per cent) of people would leave an organisation where they were poorly managed
- 8 per cent of respondents believe that working with their manager is a negative experience. 70 per cent of respondents have a positive relationship with their manager
- 28 per cent who feel that working with their manager is a negative experience do not want to be a manager in future, compared with 14 per cent who have a positive relationship with their manager
- 25 per cent of workers believe that they could do their current manager's job better (6 per cent much better and 19 per cent a little better)
- Undesirable management traits: looking for someone to blame (60 per cent), expecting staff to do as they are told without debate (36 per cent), not allowing staff to contribute (33 per cent), being obstructive (33 per cent)
- Desirable management traits: approachability (86 per cent), letting staff get on with the job (66 per cent), being team-focussed (47 per cent), being consultative (47 per cent)
- 40 per cent of workers expect to manage a team in the next five years (34 per cent managing a small team and 6 per cent managing a large team)
- 61 per cent of workers expect to learn management techniques from their own manager
- 10 per cent expect to learn management techniques from a membership body
Further information
Please contact Matt Adcock on 020 7294 3054 (office) or 07711 872753 (out of hours) / email: matt.adcock@i-l-m.com